Metallica - Some Kind Of Monster

Rating: 97/100

Reviewed by: Thomas Nielsen, February '05
Label: Third Eye
Style: Documentary style
Format: 2 DVD-set

Screen: 4:3 NTSC
Sound: Dolby Digital 5.1 and 2.0 Stereo

Running time: Appr. 2 hours 21 minutes

Back in the day, Metallica moved boundaries. Downright heroes they were.

Somewhere in the wake of the immensely successful Black album, a lot of the metal glamour disappeared, and Metallica decided to “grow up” and turn into a heavy rock band. “Load” and “Reload” definitely had their moments if you took them for what they were, but they never really cut the cheese like the glorious efforts of the past.

Somewhere in there, bass dynamo Jason leaves Metallica, Larz becomes more hated than Bush and Jaymz enters rehab. Rumours float in the press and on the internet, only emphasising that even a weakened version of Metallica is still an influence for the metal community.

When St. Anger finally hit the streets, it was indeed heavier than its two predecessors. Blatantly raw and sound-wise different from anything they’d done before.

Regardless if you liked St. Anger or not “Some Kind of Monster” is worth a buy. What started as a “The Making of…” marketing gimmick has turned into a thought-provoking piece of documentary about a bunch of 40-year-old guys who have all the success in the world but have also pushed themselves into a mental and creative dead end.

Seeing how Metallica tries to untie the knots is in many ways moving, and the two meta-themes of the media intrusion (the film crew) and the role of the therapist add really interesting layers to this film. Just notice how Phil Towles, the pro therapist, becomes so entirely involved in Metallica. He’s almost in tears when the band want to cut down on the number of therapy sessions…

The film doesn’t become less moving the second time you watch it, especially because the extra material on the bonus disc offers tons of clips that go even a bit deeper, e.g. an alternate cut of the Dave Mustaine/Lars Ulrich sequence. There’s also an interesting cut of the collaboration between Metallica and the hip-hopper Ja Rule.

Although it wasn’t quite how it was thought, this has become Metallica’s biggest promotional stunt. And not only that; it’s also a warning to all bands that want to make it big. We all have to remember to give each other a hug every now and then… Peace.